Andrew Melville Hall, St Andrews – 43 Verified Student Reviews 🏠

Back

Andrew Melville Hall -

Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value

Based on 43 user ratings

Sign in to leave a review

North Haugh, St. Andrews, Fife, KY16 9SU

💬 What Students Say

Andrew Melville Hall, situated on the North Haugh Campus of the University of St Andrews, is a self-catered accommodation option known for its welcoming atmosphere and active community. Students appreciate the hall's ship-like appearance and its proximity to the town center, science buildings, and recreational facilities, making it a convenient choice for undergraduates. The hall boasts 277 bed spaces and is wheelchair-accessible, ensuring that it caters to a diverse range of students.

With an overall rating of 4.0 out of 10, Andrew Melville Hall has garnered mixed feedback. While some students highlight the strong sense of community and the vibrant social events organized by the hall committee, others express concerns about the facilities and overall value. Many reviews mention the friendly faces and the comfortable environment, making it feel like home. The cleanliness of the shared spaces is frequently praised, contributing to a pleasant living experience.

However, it's important to note that the ratings for specific aspects like WiFi, facilities, and value hover around 4.3 out of 10. This suggests that while students enjoy the community vibe and location, there may be room for improvement in terms of amenities. Students looking for a lively and social living space will likely thrive here, but those seeking high-end facilities might want to consider their options.

Overall, Andrew Melville Hall is ideal for students who value community and convenience over luxury. It’s a place where you can easily meet new people and feel part of something bigger, making it a memorable part of your university experience.
▼ See more

✅ What Students Love

  • Strong sense of community with friendly residents and active social events.
  • Convenient location close to the town center and university facilities.
  • Clean and well-kept living spaces, contributing to a comfortable atmosphere.
  • Welcoming environment that helps students feel at home quickly.
  • Easy access to laundry facilities and bike storage.

⚠️ Things to Note

  • Overall ratings suggest that facilities and WiFi could be improved.
  • Some students feel that the value for money is not as high as expected.
  • Shared bathroom facilities may not suit everyone's preferences.
  • Limited amenities compared to other accommodation options in the area.

🎯 Best For

Students who enjoy a vibrant community and social atmosphere.

💡 Things to Know

  • Andrew Melville Hall is self-catered, so plan for your own meals.
  • Security is managed through key fobs and individual room locks.
  • The hall is wheelchair-accessible, catering to diverse needs.
  • It’s located just a short walk from both the beach and sports facilities.
  • Expect a lively atmosphere with many opportunities to meet fellow students.

❓ Common Questions

Is Andrew Melville Hall good value for money?

While the overall value rating is 4.3 out of 10, many students feel the community atmosphere makes it worthwhile.

How is the location?

The location is rated 4.3 out of 10, with easy access to the town center, beach, and university facilities.

What are the rooms like?

Rooms have a rating of 4.3 out of 10; students describe them as comfortable but suggest improvements could be made.

Are there social activities?

Yes, the hall has an active committee that organizes numerous social events, fostering a strong community spirit.

Reviews
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
One of those places you actually miss after leaving.
By Anonymous Student on Mar 13th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Really felt like part of something, not just living somewhere.
By Anonymous Student on Mar 9th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Comfortable and fun — what more can you ask for?
By Anonymous Student on Mar 8th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Nice space and a good environment.
By Anonymous Student on Mar 7th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Never any issues, just easy and reliable.
By Anonymous Student on Mar 6th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Good community energy and friendly faces.
By Anonymous Student on Mar 5th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Nothing but good memories from this place.
By Anonymous Student on Mar 4th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Everything was tidy and well kept.
By Anonymous Student on Feb 26th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
A good student atmosphere without being too much.
By Anonymous Student on Feb 11th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
A good place to meet people naturally.
By Anonymous Student on Feb 5th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Feels like home but with student energy.
By Anonymous Student on Feb 1st 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Would definitely tell others to choose here.
By Anonymous Student on Jan 27th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Everything about this place made sense.
By Anonymous Student on Jan 22nd 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Everyone was welcoming and it quickly felt like home.
By Anonymous Student on Jan 19th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
A really pleasant place to live overall.
By Anonymous Student on Jan 15th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Really felt like part of something, not just living somewhere.
By Anonymous Student on Jan 12th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Had so much fun, felt at home the whole time.
By Anonymous Student on Jan 9th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Super clean and tidy throughout. ✨
By Anonymous Student on Jan 5th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
The energy around the place was great.
By Anonymous Student on Jan 2nd 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Had an amazing time overall — 10/10!
By Anonymous Student on Dec 29th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Simple living done really well.
By Anonymous Student on Dec 25th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Felt comfortable and safe the entire time.
By Anonymous Student on Dec 21st 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Never any issues, just easy and reliable.
By Anonymous Student on Dec 19th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Safe, social and comfortable — ideal!
By Anonymous Student on Dec 16th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Never felt bored, always something happening.
By Anonymous Student on Dec 12th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Such a memorable experience overall.
By Anonymous Student on Dec 8th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Loved the convenience of everything being close by.
By Anonymous Student on Dec 4th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Everything I needed as a student, very happy.
By Anonymous Student on Dec 1st 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Never had a problem with anything important.
By Anonymous Student on Nov 28th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Felt modern and well cared for.
By Anonymous Student on Nov 25th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Close to campus and shops, very handy
By Anonymous Student on Nov 19th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Always clean, comfy, and easy to call home. ✨
By Anonymous Student on Nov 9th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Made loads of friends here, brilliant student atmosphere.
By Anonymous Student on Nov 2nd 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Great place for students, would definitely recommend!
By Anonymous Student on Oct 28th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Convenient and stress-free living.
By Anonymous Student on Oct 25th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Good atmosphere, never felt left out.
By Anonymous Student on Oct 23rd 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
The staff were super friendly and always helped out quickly
By Anonymous Student on Oct 19th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Definitely a good choice for students.
By Anonymous Student on Oct 16th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Modern rooms and good social spaces, perfect setup! ✨
By Anonymous Student on Oct 14th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Solid option for students, no complaints at all.
By Anonymous Student on Oct 11th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Good atmosphere, never felt left out.
By Anonymous Student on Oct 7th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Excellent value and location combined.
By Anonymous Student on Oct 1st 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Fun place to live, always something happening.
By Anonymous Student on Sep 26th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Social vibe was brilliant, loved it here.
By Anonymous Student on Sep 23rd 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Met so many amazing people here
By Anonymous Student on Sep 12th 2025