Andrew Melville Hall, St Andrews – 56 Verified Student Reviews 🏠
arrow_back_ios Back
Andrew Melville Hall -
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Based on 56 user ratings
North Haugh, St. Andrews, Fife, KY16 9SU
💬 What Students Say
Andrew Melville Hall, located on the North Haugh of St Andrews, is a popular choice among students at the University of St Andrews, particularly first-years. With a highly rated overall experience, students frequently commend the hall for its comfortable living spaces, friendly atmosphere, and convenient location. This self-catered accommodation features 277 bed spaces and is designed to foster a sense of community among residents. Its ship-like appearance and vibrant hall committee contribute to a unique living experience that many students cherish long after they leave.
The hall's location is one of its standout features. Situated just a 10-minute walk from the town center, residents have easy access to shops, cafes, and other amenities. For those who enjoy outdoor activities, the picturesque West Sands beach and golf courses are only a 5-minute stroll away. The University Sports Centre is even closer, just a two-minute walk from the hall, making it ideal for students who want to stay active. The excellent transport links further enhance accessibility, allowing students to navigate the beautiful town of St Andrews with ease.
When it comes to room quality, Andrew Melville Hall scores well with students, who appreciate the tidy and well-maintained spaces. Each room is equipped with its own set of keys for added security, and the shared bathroom facilities are kept in good condition. While some students note that the accommodation may not be the fanciest option available, they agree that it meets their needs effectively. The overall room rating reflects a high level of satisfaction, indicating that students find their living spaces comfortable and functional.
In terms of value for money, Andrew Melville Hall is regarded as a solid choice. While it may not be the cheapest student accommodation, many residents believe that the vibrant community and supportive atmosphere make it worth the investment. Students often mention that living here feels more like being part of a home rather than just a place to stay, which adds to the overall value of the experience.
The social atmosphere at Andrew Melville Hall is frequently highlighted in reviews. Residents appreciate the friendly and welcoming community, which helps newcomers feel at home quickly. Many students note that it’s easy to meet people and make friends, thanks to the communal spaces and social events organized by the hall committee. The lively environment contributes to a sense of belonging, with many students reflecting on their time at the hall as a memorable part of their university experience. Activities are regularly organized, ensuring that there is always something happening, which keeps boredom at bay.
What sets Andrew Melville Hall apart from other accommodations is its strong sense of community and the support provided by the hall committee. The active involvement of residents in organizing events fosters a welcoming environment where everyone can feel included. This unique atmosphere is often cited as a key reason why students would recommend the hall to others. With a good mix of people from various backgrounds, the hall promotes a friendly and social living experience that many students find appealing.
However, it’s important to consider some of the potential downsides. While many students appreciate the hall's features, some have noted that it may not be the most luxurious option available. Additionally, the shared bathroom facilities might not suit everyone, particularly those who prefer more privacy. While the communal spaces are designed to encourage social interaction, some students may find that the noise levels can be a bit high during peak times, which could be a concern for those who value a quieter living environment.
Overall, Andrew Melville Hall is best suited for first-year students or those who thrive in a lively, community-focused environment. The combination of a supportive atmosphere, convenient location, and comfortable living spaces makes it a great choice for students looking for a well-rounded university experience. Whether you are an outgoing individual eager to meet new friends or someone who enjoys a chill and relaxed atmosphere, this hall has something to offer for everyone.
In summary, Andrew Melville Hall is a reliable and enjoyable accommodation option for students at the University of St Andrews. Its strong community spirit, convenient location, and comfortable living arrangements make it a popular choice among residents. If you're looking for a place that feels like home while you embark on your university journey, this hall is definitely worth considering.
▼ See more
The hall's location is one of its standout features. Situated just a 10-minute walk from the town center, residents have easy access to shops, cafes, and other amenities. For those who enjoy outdoor activities, the picturesque West Sands beach and golf courses are only a 5-minute stroll away. The University Sports Centre is even closer, just a two-minute walk from the hall, making it ideal for students who want to stay active. The excellent transport links further enhance accessibility, allowing students to navigate the beautiful town of St Andrews with ease.
When it comes to room quality, Andrew Melville Hall scores well with students, who appreciate the tidy and well-maintained spaces. Each room is equipped with its own set of keys for added security, and the shared bathroom facilities are kept in good condition. While some students note that the accommodation may not be the fanciest option available, they agree that it meets their needs effectively. The overall room rating reflects a high level of satisfaction, indicating that students find their living spaces comfortable and functional.
In terms of value for money, Andrew Melville Hall is regarded as a solid choice. While it may not be the cheapest student accommodation, many residents believe that the vibrant community and supportive atmosphere make it worth the investment. Students often mention that living here feels more like being part of a home rather than just a place to stay, which adds to the overall value of the experience.
The social atmosphere at Andrew Melville Hall is frequently highlighted in reviews. Residents appreciate the friendly and welcoming community, which helps newcomers feel at home quickly. Many students note that it’s easy to meet people and make friends, thanks to the communal spaces and social events organized by the hall committee. The lively environment contributes to a sense of belonging, with many students reflecting on their time at the hall as a memorable part of their university experience. Activities are regularly organized, ensuring that there is always something happening, which keeps boredom at bay.
What sets Andrew Melville Hall apart from other accommodations is its strong sense of community and the support provided by the hall committee. The active involvement of residents in organizing events fosters a welcoming environment where everyone can feel included. This unique atmosphere is often cited as a key reason why students would recommend the hall to others. With a good mix of people from various backgrounds, the hall promotes a friendly and social living experience that many students find appealing.
However, it’s important to consider some of the potential downsides. While many students appreciate the hall's features, some have noted that it may not be the most luxurious option available. Additionally, the shared bathroom facilities might not suit everyone, particularly those who prefer more privacy. While the communal spaces are designed to encourage social interaction, some students may find that the noise levels can be a bit high during peak times, which could be a concern for those who value a quieter living environment.
Overall, Andrew Melville Hall is best suited for first-year students or those who thrive in a lively, community-focused environment. The combination of a supportive atmosphere, convenient location, and comfortable living spaces makes it a great choice for students looking for a well-rounded university experience. Whether you are an outgoing individual eager to meet new friends or someone who enjoys a chill and relaxed atmosphere, this hall has something to offer for everyone.
In summary, Andrew Melville Hall is a reliable and enjoyable accommodation option for students at the University of St Andrews. Its strong community spirit, convenient location, and comfortable living arrangements make it a popular choice among residents. If you're looking for a place that feels like home while you embark on your university journey, this hall is definitely worth considering.
✅ What Students Love
- Highly rated for its friendly and welcoming community atmosphere.
- Conveniently located just a short walk from the town center and university facilities.
- Rooms are well-maintained and comfortable, providing a good living experience.
- Active hall committee organizes regular social events, fostering a vibrant community.
- Strong sense of belonging, making it easy for newcomers to settle in.
⚠️ Things to Note
- Not the fanciest accommodation available, which may not appeal to everyone.
- Shared bathroom facilities may be a drawback for those who prefer privacy.
- Noise levels can be high during peak times, potentially disturbing quieter residents.
- Some may find it slightly more expensive compared to other options.
🎯 Best For
First-year students or those looking for a vibrant and social living environment.
💡 Things to Know
- Andrew Melville Hall is self-catered, so be prepared to cook your own meals.
- The hall is wheelchair accessible, making it suitable for students with mobility needs.
- Residents are provided with key fobs for secure entry to the building.
- Laundry facilities are available on-site for convenience.
❓ Common Questions
Is Andrew Melville Hall good value for money?
While not the cheapest option, many students find the community atmosphere and support worth the investment.
How is the location?
Located on North Haugh, it is only a 10-minute walk from the town center and close to the university and beach.
What are the rooms like?
Rooms are well-kept and comfortable, with a good rating from residents.
What is the social life like at Andrew Melville Hall?
The social life is vibrant, with regular events and a friendly atmosphere that encourages interaction.
Are there communal areas?
Yes, there are communal spaces designed to promote socialization among residents.
Reviews
1 of 58
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Living in Andrew Melville Hall has been a pivotal part of my student experience. it's not just about the decent rooms but also the sense of community that comes from shared kitchens and common areas, where friendships easily spark over late-night snacks. while it might not be the newest place around, the atmosphere makes it a solid base for what life at St Andrews is all about.
By user525069 on Apr 28th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Really missed having a proper kitchen space to cook my own meals. relying on the dining hall food got a bit tiring, especially when you crave something specific.
By user922513 on Apr 23rd 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Weekdays are a bit wild at melville, so planning my study routine around the inevitable noise was crucial. it's lively, which can be a laugh, but trying to find peace for those readings was a juggling act. i found myself sneaking off to the library more often than i'd like, which was a bit of a hassle given melville's location.
By user114492 on Apr 18th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Felt a bit institutional when i first walked into andrew melville hall, with its long corridors and uniform rooms. over time, the bustling mix of students and the common areas filled with chatter made it feel more like the heart of student life than a sterile dorm.
By user593443 on Apr 13th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Would definitely stay here again because it's so easy to make friends in the kitchen. sure, it can get a bit noisy sometimes but that's kind of expected when everyone's trying to socialise. the location is really convenient for classes and the price is pretty fair for what you get.
By user911461 on Apr 11th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
When everyone gathers in the common room for movie nights, it really shows how welcoming and lively the hall can be.
By user401934 on Apr 10th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Always appreciate a friendly vibe in student halls and Andrew Melville nails it. everyone seemed happy to chat, and it made settling in feel way less daunting.
By user160297 on Apr 6th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Rooms in andrew melville hall aren't too fancy, but they're comfortable enough for settling in. it's mostly about the people you meet and the vibe in the common areas that makes living there enjoyable. being close to the uni is great for those early morning classes.
By user816868 on Apr 5th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Check-in day was kind of stressful but the staff were chill and helped with all my questions. compared to other halls, the rooms here felt more spacious and had better storage options 📚 which was a lifesaver when unpacking all my stuff.
By user974200 on Apr 2nd 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Nothing beats waking up to the stunning views of the coastline from my room. it's seriously breathtaking and makes those gloomy mornings a bit more bearable. plus, it's just easy to get to classes, which means more time for grabbing a coffee on the way.
By user428082 on Mar 31st 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Noticed that every time you pass the common area, there's someone playing a tune on the old piano. it's both relaxing and kinda comforting, like having a bit of consistent background music in your life.
By user603699 on Mar 28th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Found settling in easier than expected with the friendly crowd here. before long, it started feeling like a second home, surrounded by people who genuinely care.
By user929086 on Mar 25th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Everyone's super chill, and you end up making friends just by wandering around 😅.
By user848532 on Mar 19th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Was expecting the usual bare-bones dorm vibe, but the place surprised me with its warmth and social atmosphere. turns out, it's actually a bit of a wrench to say goodbye to.
By user159026 on Mar 13th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Overlooks lovely greenery which makes it feel a bit different from the usual concrete blocks. easy to get a chat going with people here, especially in the communal areas.
By user983727 on Mar 9th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Considering all the stories I'd heard, Andrew Melville Hall was surprisingly more social than expected.
By user431008 on Mar 8th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Noticed people were really open and friendly, easy to chat with in the communal areas. felt relaxed and welcoming, perfect for settling in
By user654008 on Mar 7th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Always thought I'd feel out of place in such a big hall, but it turns out it has this strange way of easing you into it. you get used to seeing familiar faces at the oddest times, like at breakfast or when you randomly bump into someone at the vending machine. it just makes the whole experience of living in a larger community kind of comforting.
By user360742 on Mar 6th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Wifi can be a bit spotty at times, which is annoying when trying to stream lectures or finish assignments. while it's not a dealbreaker, i find it frustrating having to disconnect and connect again just to get it back up. once that's sorted, everything else here feels pretty nice for student life.
By user310537 on Mar 5th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Students here seemed genuinely outgoing, always up for a chat in the common areas. honestly felt easier making mates at andrew melville hall than i expected.
By user668792 on Mar 4th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Andrew Melville Hall felt like living in a piece of modern architecture history, with its unique design and spacious layout. I remember being pleasantly surprised by how robust and cozy the rooms felt, especially during the chilly winter months. It's a place where making friends seemed inevitable, with so many common areas fostering a real sense of community.
By user339174 on Feb 26th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
You'll notice the morning light in the dining area makes breakfast feel a bit more inviting. it's one of those little things that makes waking up early for lectures a tad easier. i think this place understands how such simple comforts can have a decent impact on a student's day.
By user264618 on Feb 11th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Would definitely go back to melville hall given how easy it was to make friends there. the student community felt genuine and inviting, much more so than other places i've lived.
By user322223 on Feb 5th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Woke up one morning to sunlight streaming through the massive windows and realized i hadn't felt this cozy in ages. major props for how quiet it stays even during exams.
By user613135 on Feb 1st 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
People at andrew melville hall seem to genuinely enjoy each other's company, with lots of impromptu gatherings and lively communal spaces.
By user753753 on Jan 27th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
View from my room was surprisingly nice; looking out over the grassy fields to the uni buildings really added a touch of calm to my study sessions. quiet corridors after hours made it feel like a little escape from the usual clamor of student life.
By user746969 on Jan 22nd 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Walking into andrew melville hall, i instantly felt a sense of belonging. there's just something about the atmosphere that makes it comforting and less intimidating for us quieter types.
By user721284 on Jan 19th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Spent many evenings chatting with mates while watching the sunset over the North Sea from my window, it was pretty stunning. really made settling into uni life easier, being in such a stunning spot.
By user432488 on Jan 15th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Walking through andrew melville hall, you feel like you’re stepping into more than just a place to sleep. it’s got this sort of warm buzz, where people actually stop to chat in the corridors. i reckon it helps ease that first-year chaos when you’ve got a home base like this.
By user905710 on Jan 12th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Adjusting to life here took a bit of time, but it really did feel like a second home quickly. the mix of people you meet in the common areas keeps things interesting and lively. made quite a few friends just by hanging out in the lounge, which was unexpected but nice.
By user752639 on Jan 9th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Having ensuite bathrooms in a dorm was honestly such a bonus. it made late-night study sessions way more manageable without the hassle of shared facilities, which kept stress levels down in a new country.
By user608860 on Jan 5th 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Met some amazing people in the common room here, but honestly, the building felt a bit dated 😬. location wise, though, spot on.
By user572954 on Jan 2nd 2026
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Folks working at andrew melville are legends. always down for a chat and make the place feel welcoming, which is kind of crucial for first years far from home. they helped me find my way around more times than i can count.
By user542905 on Dec 29th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Tucked away in the corner of the building, the common room was a surprise. it became my go-to spot for meeting new people and decompressing after classes. never expected it to be such a lively hub, but it turned out to be the heart of the hall for me.
By user142446 on Dec 25th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Compared to other halls i've seen, andrew melville hall is a breath of fresh air. the rooms feel so much more spacious and well laid out. i felt like i actually had my own corner to study in peace without having to awkwardly manoeuvre around furniture.
By user482867 on Dec 21st 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Wandering back from the library late at night feels totally safe, and the view across the fields in the morning is just ace. the staff here genuinely care and always seem to be around when you need something. living here means there's always someone to share a cuppa and a chat with, makes everything feel a bit more like home.
By user377034 on Dec 19th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Felt super welcomed from day one, and you really can't overstate the convenience of having everything so close. rooms are a decent size for what they cost, definitely chill😅 if you're looking for somewhere laid-back yet lively.
By user885760 on Dec 16th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Walls are paper thin and you can hear pretty much everything your neighbour does. feels like a permanent eavesdropping session, which isn't great when you're trying to concentrate or catch some sleep.
By user609857 on Dec 12th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Much more welcoming than the cramped places I have stayed in before, with plenty of space in the common areas for studying.
By user249729 on Dec 8th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Back when i moved in, the thing that really surprised me was how welcoming everyone was. the common area kind of became the go-to spot for meeting people and just hanging out after classes. it's nice knowing you can always find someone to chat with or head out with if you're feeling social.
By user390813 on Dec 4th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Found it easy to balance studying and socializing with everything so accessible.
By user452939 on Dec 1st 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Settling into Andrew Melville Hall felt surprisingly smooth. Despite being a bit of a maze at first, navigating the corridors quickly become second nature. It’s amazing how quickly you start to know everyone by sight, and it helps that the common areas bring a lot of us together naturally.
By user523514 on Nov 28th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Moving into andrew melville hall felt like a step into the future with its modern design. the views from the windows really do make a difference, especially when you're stuck studying inside. it doesn't take long for it to feel like home with everyone being so welcoming.
By user888187 on Nov 25th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Designed by James Stirling, Andrew Melville Hall stands out with its unique architectural style that feels a bit like living in a modernist exhibit 😮. compared to other accommodations, it's got this quirky charm that makes it feel more like a home than just a student hall. the place fosters a sense of community that's rare to find.
By user762365 on Nov 19th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Sometimes it feels a bit too quiet here, almost like everyone's holed up in their rooms. it'd be nice if there were more opportunities for social events, especially for introverts like me who struggle to break the ice. though the rooms are nice, it can get a bit lonely.
By user908692 on Nov 9th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Definitely would choose Andrew Melville Hall again,it's where I found my little community. the open layout and relaxed vibe make it a place you just want to return to.
By user813451 on Nov 2nd 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Noticed how there's always someone around for a chat in the common areas, which is nice when assignments start to pile up 😅. the little events they do every now and then create a great atmosphere for meeting new people and it's a dependable place to just unwind after a busy week.
By user849748 on Oct 28th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Lots of friendly faces around Andrew Melville Hall. people here seem relaxed but are open to a good chat if you are. it's a chill place overall, which I appreciate 😌
By user246431 on Oct 25th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Met some really great people in the common room who turned into my closest mates. felt like we were all in it together from the start, which made adjusting to first year a lot easier
By user609628 on Oct 23rd 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Have to admit, i wasn't sure about the brutalist architecture when i first got here, but it kinda grows on you. once inside, it's surprisingly comfortable, almost like a 60s cosiness , if that's even a thing. can see why first-years like settling here, especially given how easy it is to make mates.
By user938836 on Oct 19th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Getting along with everyone is a breeze at melville. the common areas make it easy to bump into people and the overall vibe is welcoming, helping everyone settle in quickly.
By user368710 on Oct 16th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Didn't expect the hall to look like something out of a futuristic movie. the design is all sleek and modern, way different from the typical old stone buildings around town.
By user808086 on Oct 14th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Found myself genuinely surprised by how peaceful the surroundings are, given it's student accommodation. had imagined it would be way louder with all of us around, but turns out there's a good balance between quiet time for study and social buzz when you want it.
By user387418 on Oct 11th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
So many student accommodations can feel a bit generic, but andrew melville hall has this distinctive zig-zag design that makes it stand out. there's a sense of character and community that shaped my first year in a way i didn't anticipate. plus, being surrounded by other first-years in such a unique setting made it feel more like a small supportive village.
By user298705 on Oct 7th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Stands out from other halls with its unique, brutalist architecture that gives it character and charm. communal spaces are lively enough for meeting people, but quiet enough for studying too, making it a perfect balance for student life.
By user523764 on Oct 1st 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Always seemed like people were up for a chat in the common areas, which made it quite lively.
By user329872 on Sep 26th 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Hearing about the social life here doesn't quite do it justice until you actually experience it. it's like everyone just knows how to make friends and have a laugh. being welcomed so warmly really helped me settle into uni life much quicker than i thought possible.
By user931601 on Sep 23rd 2025
Overall
Room
Wifi
Food
Facilities
Location
Value
Staff here are genuine and approachable, making settling in way easier than I expected. met some of the nicest people who work hard to keep things running smoothly and always greet you with a smile.
By user348591 on Sep 12th 2025
Review published! ✓