Evil Eye, York – 57 Verified Student Reviews 🍻

Back
add_circle Add your night out listing
Evil Eye — student bar photo
Evil Eye — student bar photo

Evil Eye -

Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking

Based on 57 user ratings

42 Stonegate, York YO1 8AS, United Kingdom

💬 What Students Say

Evil Eye is a relaxed bar located conveniently close to the University of York, making it an ideal spot for students looking to unwind after a long day of classes. This venue is celebrated for its extensive menu of inventive cocktails, smoothies, and milkshakes, which are crafted with fresh ingredients by friendly and well-trained staff. The bar has a unique character, often described as bizarre and wonderful, offering an escape from the typical nightlife found in York. With its cozy and inviting atmosphere, Evil Eye has become a popular hangout for students who appreciate a laid-back night out.

The atmosphere at Evil Eye is frequently highlighted in student reviews. Many patrons describe it as a chill environment where everyone is there to enjoy themselves without any pressure or drama. This relaxed vibe is complemented by a friendly crowd, which often includes familiar faces, creating a sense of community that students appreciate. The bar's spacious layout allows for plenty of room to move around, ensuring that it never feels too packed, even during busy nights. Students enjoy the mix of chill and chaos, which adds to the overall experience, making it a place where good times can be had without feeling overwhelmed.

When it comes to drinks, Evil Eye strikes a balance between quality and reasonable pricing. While some reviews note that it may not be the cheapest option in town, many students feel that the quality of the cocktails and the overall experience justify the price. The bar's inventive cocktails are a major draw, with a range that caters to various tastes. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cocktail or something more adventurous, Evil Eye offers something for everyone. The drink deals are often mentioned as being decent, making it a solid choice for students looking to enjoy a night out without breaking the bank.

The student crowd at Evil Eye tends to be lively and fun-loving, with many reviews noting that it’s a great spot for a night out with friends. The bar gets particularly busy on weekends, but it also sees a good turnout during the week, especially on student nights. Many students appreciate the quick entry and the absence of long queues, which allows them to get right into the fun. The atmosphere often feels electric, especially when the music is on point, encouraging many to dance and let loose.

What makes Evil Eye stand out from other bars in the area is its unique character and the sense of community it fosters. Many students have remarked on the bar's ability to create lasting memories, often returning for more good times. The staff are frequently praised for their friendliness and attentiveness, contributing to the overall welcoming vibe of the venue. This attention to creating a positive experience for patrons is a key factor in why students keep coming back.

However, like any venue, Evil Eye does have its downsides. Some reviews mention that while the atmosphere is generally great, queues can occasionally be a bit long during peak times, which may lead to some frustration. Additionally, while many find the drink prices reasonable, others feel that it could be a bit on the pricier side compared to other local options. There are also notes that while the vibe is mostly chill, it can get wild towards the end of the night, which might not suit everyone looking for a more relaxed evening. Lastly, while the music is often praised, it’s worth noting that preferences can vary widely, and not every night may feature tunes to everyone’s taste.

Overall, Evil Eye is best suited for students who enjoy a relaxed yet lively atmosphere where they can kick back and socialize with friends. The bar is perfect for those who appreciate good cocktails and a friendly crowd, making it a solid choice for anyone looking to enjoy a memorable night out in York. Whether you’re unwinding after classes or gearing up for the weekend, Evil Eye offers a unique blend of chill and excitement that keeps students coming back for more.

Before heading out, here are a few practical tips to keep in mind. First, consider arriving early, especially on weekends, to avoid potential queues. Second, check out their cocktail menu in advance; with so many inventive options, you might want to plan your order! Third, if you enjoy a particular drink, don’t hesitate to ask the staff for recommendations or variations. Fourth, be prepared for a lively atmosphere, especially later in the evening, as the vibe tends to ramp up. Lastly, remember that while the bar can be busy, the spacious layout allows for plenty of movement, so you can find a comfortable spot to enjoy your night.

In summary, Evil Eye is more than just a bar; it’s a place where students can relax, enjoy good drinks, and create lasting memories with friends. With its unique character and welcoming atmosphere, it’s no wonder that this venue has become a favorite among the student crowd at the University of York.
▼ See more

✅ What Students Love

  • Relaxed and inviting atmosphere perfect for unwinding with friends.
  • Extensive menu of inventive cocktails and drinks made with fresh ingredients.
  • Friendly and attentive staff contribute to a welcoming vibe.
  • Spacious layout ensures it never feels too packed, even on busy nights.
  • Good mix of chill and lively energy, making it suitable for various moods.

⚠️ Things to Note

  • Queues can be a bit long during peak times, especially on weekends.
  • Some students find drink prices slightly higher compared to other local bars.
  • The atmosphere can become wild towards the end of the night, which may not suit everyone.
  • Music preferences may vary, and not every night will cater to all tastes.

🎯 Best For

Students looking for a laid-back bar with good cocktails and a friendly atmosphere.

💡 Things to Know

  • Arrive early on weekends to avoid long queues.
  • Check out the cocktail menu in advance to plan your order.
  • Don't hesitate to ask staff for drink recommendations.
  • Be prepared for a lively atmosphere later in the evening.
  • The spacious layout allows for comfortable movement, even when busy.

❓ Common Questions

What is Evil Eye like?

Evil Eye is a relaxed bar known for its inventive cocktails and chill atmosphere, perfect for unwinding with friends.

Is it good value?

While not the cheapest option, many students feel the quality of drinks and atmosphere justify the prices.

When do students go to Evil Eye?

Students frequent Evil Eye on weekends, but it also sees a good crowd during the week, especially on student nights.

What drinks do they offer?

Evil Eye offers an extensive menu of inventive cocktails, smoothies, and milkshakes made with fresh ingredients.

Is it easy to get in?

Entry is generally quick, with few issues reported regarding queues, especially during less busy times.

Evil Eye — student bar photo
Evil Eye — student bar photo
Reviews
1 of 58
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Crowd control could use a bit of work here, as it sometimes gets packed and the flow feels a bit off. While the atmosphere buzzes with energy, waiting at the bar can stretch longer than you'd like. Still, the staff handle it well enough, and it doesn’t take away from the fun of the night.
By user177653 (York) on Jul 24th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
I've been here a few times and it's always buzzing with energy. Would definitely return for the lively atmosphere. 🎉
By user995755 (York) on Jul 19th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
This place offers decent drinks at a reasonable price and manages to attract a good crowd. It's a reliable spot to unwind and not worry about overspending, which is a refreshing change from other venues.
By user950264 (York) on Jul 14th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye surprised me in a good way, and I think I'll be heading back again. The prices for drinks are pretty fair, and the music's awesome—it really makes for a fun evening. I love that it's easy to have a conversation without having to shout, which is crucial for me.
By user197261 (York) on Jul 9th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Dancing here felt special as the crowd was filled with locals who really knew how to enjoy themselves.
By user501583 (York) on Jul 3rd 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Crowd at Evil Eye surprised me with its mix of locals and students, making it a lively scene. however, the music was a bit hit or miss; some songs really dragged on when I hoped for something more upbeat and fun.
By user869132 (York) on Jun 28th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Value for money here isn’t what I expected. drinks felt overpriced compared to what I’ve seen back home, especially given the crowd and atmosphere. still, the energy made it worth a visit, so it was an interesting experience overall.
By user782041 (York) on Jun 23rd 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
The aroma of spices at Evil Eye immediately grabs your attention, sparking curiosity about the food. It's those unique scents and the cool decor that really set the tone for a fun night out here.
By user728801 (York) on Jun 16th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
People here really know how to embrace the music, turning every night into a mini party that feels so alive. it’s refreshing to be around a crowd that just wants to enjoy themselves
By user794811 (York) on Jun 11th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Located in a lively area, this place struck a balance with its noise levels that allowed for good conversation without losing that energetic buzz. Music mixed nicely into the background, creating a lively atmosphere without overwhelming the experience, which suited my night perfectly. Enjoying drinks while able to chat made it a great hangout, where the lively energy kept it interesting.
By user557109 (York) on Jun 6th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Being from a small town, it's quite the experience to find myself in a place so different. The vibe is inviting, and the people are friendly, making it a spot I'd consider revisiting. However, the drink selection could use a bit more variety to suit my taste.
By user441304 (York) on May 29th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
This place can feel a bit chaotic, but that's part of its charm on a night out. It's a good spot to run into classmates, and there's always a lively vibe here. 🎶
By user682100 (York) on May 24th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye's decor is a standout with its quirky, eclectic charm. It's a refreshing change from the usual bar scene and makes for a fun experience.
By user663005 (York) on May 19th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye is always bustling, yet everything runs like clockwork. It's impressive how they manage to maintain such seamless operations while making sure everyone feels looked after.
By user683052 (York) on May 12th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye has a genuinely relaxed atmosphere that instantly puts you at ease. The drinks are well-crafted and unique, making it an awesome spot to unwind and try something new. It's one of those places where you feel like you're getting a little extra care in every sip. 🍹
By user661409 (York) on May 6th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
If you're into a vibrant scene, Evil Eye delivers with its energetic crowd and lively music.
By user258300 (York) on Apr 30th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
The music here is way louder and wilder than I expected. It's usually easy to find a spot, and the real draw is people-watching and those surprise encounters that happen among such a crowd. Never thought a bar could feel so alive 😮
By user319618 (York) on Apr 22nd 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
My first visit here, I noticed how genuinely friendly the bartenders were. They took time to chat, making it feel more like a conversation than just another drink order. 😊
By user323282 (York) on Apr 17th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
There's no need to worry about long waits or messy floors here, making for a seamless and enjoyable night. The presence of fellow students contributes to a laid-back atmosphere, making it feel like a place where you belong.
By user217965 (York) on Apr 11th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye was unexpectedly lively for a Tuesday night. Despite having an early lecture the next day, the buzzing atmosphere and rhythmic tunes made it difficult not to enjoy the good vibes.
By user183368 (York) on Apr 10th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Noticed how the chill seating arrangements feel like they've been scattered with care, creating cozy little friend clusters. it's laid-back but still buzzing, and prices keep it student-friendly.
By user866827 (York) on Apr 6th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Heard a lot about evil eye's cocktails and it actually lived up to the hype. wasn't expecting such a relaxed vibe after hearing about its popularity, though. even with the long queue, once you're in it's a comfortable spot to unwind.
By user964478 (York) on Mar 30th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Absolutely would go back because it's perfect for meeting new friends while sipping on their wickedly creative drinks in a lively setting.
By user458728 (York) on Mar 25th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
The atmosphere here is buzzing, always lively and engaging. It feels more like hanging out with friends than just another night out, even when it gets packed. 🙌
By user321939 (York) on Mar 21st 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
This place has such an easygoing vibe that you'll find yourself staying longer than planned. The staff are super welcoming and helpful, always ready for a chat, which just makes everything feel even more laid-back. It's the kind of spot where you can unwind and let the world drift by. 😊
By user483124 (York) on Mar 14th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
This place keeps things relaxed, unlike spots that are often too much. Everything runs smoothly here, making it easy to unwind without any hassle.
By user989469 (York) on Mar 2nd 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
After a long day of lectures, this place turned out to be a perfect spot to unwind. The bartender mixed drinks with skill while the gentle buzz of conversations filled the air. Observing others relax and chat made the evening feel like a casual get-together.
By user977695 (York) on Feb 12th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Finding a spot where you can unwind can be a challenge, but this place hits the mark! The unique cocktails are a standout, and the chilled atmosphere is exactly what you need for a break from the bustling city life. The combination of tasty drinks and a relaxing vibe makes it feel like your own little escape. 🍹
By user526492 (York) on Feb 9th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
This place is in such a lively area, but I was pleasantly surprised to find it still had a pretty refreshing atmosphere.
By user786530 (York) on Feb 1st 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
This place is the go-to spot for students looking for a fun night out with friends. I even bumped into a few classmates, which just shows how popular it is with us. It's definitely a favourite! 🎉
By user426192 (York) on Jan 26th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye is a relaxed spot where you can chat with staff who are often students themselves, creating an easygoing vibe. It's a chill place to hang out, especially when it's not too busy.
By user923396 (York) on Jan 22nd 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Finding a space to relax and unwind can be tough, but this place manages to stand out with its unique drinks and comfortable setting. The atmosphere is refreshingly laid-back, and it's easy to settle in without feeling squeezed in, unlike many other spots.
By user393889 (York) on Jan 18th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Finding comfort at this place was effortless with the inviting atmosphere. 😊 I started with one drink, and before I knew it, it felt like a cozy second home, buzzing with just the right amount of energy. Fitting in happens quickly, which is such a relief when you're new to a uni city.
By user496996 (York) on Jan 14th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
The bartenders here have a knack for making you feel right at home with their friendly interactions and exceptional drink recommendations. It's not just about the drinks; their engaging conversations add a special touch to the evening, making each visit memorable.
By user581580 (York) on Jan 10th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Last weekend, my mates and I decided to visit this place for a change of scene, and it turned out to be just what we needed. The crowd was fun, and the cocktails hit the mark, making it an easy spot to chill.
By user776531 (York) on Jan 6th 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye is my go-to spot for winding down after intense study sessions. The relaxed vibe is perfect for catching up with friends over drinks, and the welcoming crowd makes it an easy favorite.
By user142624 (York) on Jan 2nd 2026
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye is super convenient for students, being just a short walk from campus! 😊 The drinks are both creative and refreshing, making it an ideal spot to unwind after hitting the books all day. I can definitely see myself popping in regularly for a relaxing evening.
By user430428 (York) on Dec 29th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Staff seemed kind of distracted and preoccupied, which was a bummer. still enjoyed the unique cocktail combinations, just wish the attention to service was a bit more consistent.
By user268611 (York) on Dec 24th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Music at Evil Eye was absolutely banging and set the perfect tone for a memorable night with friends 🎵
By user993666 (York) on Dec 19th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Crowd's got this laid-back vibe that just makes chatting up random folks feel like a breeze. ended up having the most unexpected convos that made the night pretty special if you ask me.
By user320018 (York) on Dec 15th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye is such a refreshing find! The inventive drinks are perfect for those who love something fruity and different. It's a great spot to chill and chat with friends without the typical pub noise.
By user453824 (York) on Dec 11th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Wouldn't have thought a place with such unique cocktails would be so chill. the crowd's a mix of students and locals, making it feel laid back and friendly. definitely a fun spot to relax nearby.
By user801461 (York) on Dec 4th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
This place has a vibe that instantly makes you feel at home. The laughter reverberating off the walls just lifts your spirits, and any stress from lectures simply disappears.
By user732281 (York) on Nov 30th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Drinks here are way more creative than most places around, and you can tell they're using fresh ingredients. even on busy nights the bar keeps things moving quickly which makes it stand out in a city where you're often stuck waiting.
By user657015 (York) on Nov 25th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Spending time here is a regular highlight of my week, hanging with friends and exploring the diverse drink options. This place provides a welcoming environment that's perfect for both great chats and a few laughs.
By user881686 (York) on Nov 20th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye is a lively spot where the energy is infectious, largely thanks to the bartenders who keep the atmosphere buzzing. It's amazing how they manage to be so efficient while making you feel right at home, like you're just catching up with friends. One bartender even impressed me by remembering my drink order from months ago.
By user803602 (York) on Nov 14th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye isn't just your typical student spot. The atmosphere is relaxed, making it easy to unwind without the hassle of loud music. I'll definitely be returning.
By user421353 (York) on Nov 7th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye is the kind of place that strikes a nice balance between lively and laid-back. You can enjoy unique drinks while having proper conversations with friends, which isn't always the case in busy bars.
By user506027 (York) on Oct 31st 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
The atmosphere here is reminiscent of hanging out with an old friend. Unlike other places where staff are always preoccupied, they actually recognize you, which adds a welcoming touch. It's nice not to just blend into the crowd. 😊
By user740398 (York) on Oct 26th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye offers a laid-back atmosphere that's ideal for relaxing. The staff are knowledgeable and make creative drinks, which adds to the overall welcoming vibe of the place.
By user208779 (York) on Oct 23rd 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Bouncers were surprisingly chill, which made getting in with a group much easier.
By user267018 (York) on Oct 19th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
After my lectures, I find this place perfect for unwinding. It's become a go-to spot in York for kicking back and relaxing 😅.
By user228135 (York) on Oct 16th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Met some brilliant people here and the drinks menu never seems to run out of surprises.
By user680028 (York) on Oct 12th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Here is the perfect spot to break away from the study routine with some friends. The creative cocktails served here are an absolute delight, offering a refreshing twist to the usual options. It's a go-to for when you need a change of pace, and the fun atmosphere just adds to the experience. 🍹
By user991850 (York) on Oct 8th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye has a bartender with a knack for conversation and an impressive variety of drinks. Chatting with them made the night feel genuinely welcoming and familiar.
By user774664 (York) on Oct 2nd 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Drinks here are unique and well thought out, perfect if you're a sucker for something different. worth dropping by with a couple of mates when you're nearby rather than another predictable night at home.
By user422221 (York) on Sep 28th 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Evil Eye has an incredible team who not only excel at making drinks but also love engaging with their customers. The passion from the staff is infectious, and it instantly made me feel like part of the community. It's a spot that effortlessly turns first-timers into regulars.
By user826294 (York) on Sep 23rd 2025
Overall
Cleanliness
Music
Price
Queue
Smoking
Chatted with a friend who said evil eye is their new fave spot for cocktails. super chill vibe and the staff aren’t pretentious at all.
By user513100 (York) on Jan 1st 2024