Penny Black, Sheffield – 32 Verified Student Reviews 🍻

infoImage credit: https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.tripadvisor.co.uk%2FLocationPhotoDirectLink-g186364-d5979354-i90732967-The_Penny_Black-Sheffield_South_Yorkshire_England.html&psig=AOvVaw01qY-tTxtnX0iML6HXLmKP&ust=1707214408413000&source=images&cd=vfe&opi=89978449&ved=0CBUQjhxqFwoTCODK5LL7k4QDFQAAAAAdAAAAABAP

Penny Black -

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Based on 32 user ratings

Pond Hill, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 2BG, United Kingdom

💬 What Students Say

Located in the heart of Sheffield, Penny Black is a vibrant venue that combines traditional pub charm with a modern twist. Known for its welcoming atmosphere, this Greene King establishment is perfect for students looking to unwind after a long week or enjoy a fun night out with friends. With a dog-friendly beer garden, delicious pub fare, and regular events like live music and quiz nights, it’s a local favorite that promises a good time.

Students frequently rave about the upbeat vibe at Penny Black, describing the atmosphere as buzzing and filled with good energy. The music selection is often highlighted, with many mentioning the 'unreal' playlists that feature the latest student anthems. Whether you’re looking to dance the night away or simply catch up with friends over drinks, this venue caters to a variety of moods and preferences, making it a versatile spot for any night out.

Review patterns indicate that Penny Black is a place where students can feel relaxed and safe, with a friendly crowd that fosters a sense of community. Many have noted that the staff are approachable and efficient, helping to keep the queues moving quickly. While the overall ratings sit at 4.3/10, with specific scores like 4.0 for value and 4.2 for cleanliness, the positive experiences shared by patrons suggest that the fun atmosphere often outweighs any minor drawbacks.

Penny Black is ideal for students who enjoy a lively pub scene with a mix of dancing, socializing, and enjoying good music. It’s a place where you can easily meet new people and have a great laugh, making it one of the top choices for a night out in Sheffield.

▼ See more

✅ What Students Love

Great atmosphere with a lively student vibe.
Fantastic music selection, often featuring student anthems.
Friendly staff and quick-moving queues.
Affordable drinks and good value for students.
Regular events like live music and quiz nights.

⚠️ Things to Note

Overall ratings suggest room for improvement in cleanliness.
Some students mentioned it can get quite busy, especially on weekends.
While the atmosphere is fun, it might not suit those looking for a quieter night.

🎯 Best For

Students looking for a lively and social pub atmosphere with great music.

💡 Things to Know

Expect a mix of students and a welcoming crowd.
The venue can get busy, especially during peak hours, so plan accordingly.
The music style is predominantly upbeat and features popular student tracks.
Penny Black is dog-friendly, so feel free to bring your furry friend along.
Drinks are considered good value, making it a budget-friendly choice for students.

❓ Common Questions

What is Penny Black like?

Penny Black is a lively pub known for its great atmosphere, friendly crowd, and excellent music.

How long is the queue?

The queue moves fast according to reviews, so you won’t have to wait long.

Is it good value?

Yes, many students find the drinks to be good value for money.

What music does Penny Black play?

Penny Black features a mix of upbeat tracks, often including popular student anthems.

Reviews

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Always end up having a great laugh here with friends.

By Anonymous Student on Mar 13th 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Music was top tier and the vibe unmatched.

By Anonymous Student on Mar 3rd 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Every night feels different but always fun.

By Anonymous Student on Feb 9th 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Everyone was smiling — good energy all around.

By Anonymous Student on Feb 3rd 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Perfect spot for unwinding after a long week.

By Anonymous Student on Jan 28th 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Great crowd, decent drinks, no drama – just fun.

By Anonymous Student on Jan 23rd 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Unreal atmosphere — can’t beat it.

By Anonymous Student on Jan 18th 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Had a top night — definitely coming back.

By Anonymous Student on Jan 14th 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Friendly team and great music every time.

By Anonymous Student on Jan 10th 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

The playlist was unreal, proper student anthems.

By Anonymous Student on Jan 6th 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Perfect for a quick catch-up that turns into hours.

By Anonymous Student on Jan 2nd 2026

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Really nice spot — great atmosphere and easy vibes.

By Anonymous Student on Dec 29th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Just pure fun, no stress — loved it.

By Anonymous Student on Dec 23rd 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Good atmosphere, felt lively and safe.

By Anonymous Student on Dec 19th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

So relaxed and fun — can’t fault it.

By Anonymous Student on Dec 15th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Always end up meeting new people here.

By Anonymous Student on Dec 10th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Couldn’t stop smiling all night — proper good times.

By Anonymous Student on Dec 3rd 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

The place just has that student buzz about it. ⚡️

By Anonymous Student on Nov 28th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Atmosphere was buzzing!

By Anonymous Student on Nov 23rd 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

The perfect way to end a long week.

By Anonymous Student on Nov 17th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Great night out, music was spot on and the vibe was brilliant.

By Anonymous Student on Nov 9th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Drinks were good value and the crowd was unreal!

By Anonymous Student on Nov 2nd 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Perfect spot for dancing and relaxing with friends.

By Anonymous Student on Oct 27th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Good value drinks and a lively crowd, perfect for students.

By Anonymous Student on Oct 24th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Always end up having a great laugh here with friends.

By Anonymous Student on Oct 20th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Such a good laugh, everyone was just there for a good time!

By Anonymous Student on Oct 16th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Queue moved fast and staff were sound.

By Anonymous Student on Oct 13th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Perfect spot for dancing and relaxing with friends.

By Anonymous Student on Oct 9th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Great vibe overall, one of my favourite student nights.

By Anonymous Student on Oct 3rd 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

One of the best places to go out with friends from uni.

By Anonymous Student on Sep 29th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Good mix of people and a very welcoming vibe.

By Anonymous Student on Sep 24th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Atmosphere is always buzzing, exactly what you want on a night out.

By Anonymous Student on Sep 15th 2025

Overall

Cleanliness

Music

Price

Queue

Smoking

Cozy and intimate, perfect for a relaxed evening with friends.

By anonymous on Dec 4th 2024